Simon Levy, 40, has been handed a whole life sentence at the Old Bailey for the murders of Carmenza Valencia-Trujillo, 53, and Sheryl Wilkins, 39, as well as the rape of a third woman.

The killings occurred in 2025, with Valencia-Trujillo murdered in March and Wilkins five months later. The rape took place in the same Tottenham car park where Wilkins' body was later discovered.

Failures in Law Enforcement

Levy was out on bail and under police surveillance when he committed these crimes, despite a history of sexual offences dating back to 2018. The Metropolitan Police Service (Met) and Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) have acknowledged a series of critical errors that allowed Levy to remain free.

Met Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley described the handling of Levy's case as a "whole system failing," noting that repeated requests for remand were denied by courts, leaving a dangerous offender on the streets.

Details of the Crimes and Trial

  • Levy suffocated both victims during sexually motivated attacks.
  • Valencia-Trujillo was found in an abandoned block of flats in south-east London.
  • Wilkins was discovered behind a car park wall near Tottenham High Road.
  • The woman Levy raped had informed police of his residence but was not properly interviewed until after the murders.

Judge Mark Lucraft KC emphasized Levy's disturbing obsession with sexual violence, referencing his internet history and collection of crime-related press clippings. He stated the whole life sentence was warranted, citing the severity and aggravating factors of Levy's offences.

Impact on Victims' Families

Sheryl Wilkins' sister, Lindsey Hicks, expressed profound grief and condemned Levy, saying, "I hope you rot in prison for the rest of your life." Their mother, Mary Wilkins, found some solace in the sentence, believing it prevents further harm.

Calls for Systemic Reform

London Mayor Sir Sadiq Khan criticized the multiple agency failures that allowed Levy to continue offending, calling for a comprehensive review to prevent future tragedies. Shadow Justice Secretary Nick Timothy and former safeguarding minister Jess Phillips also highlighted the justice system's shortcomings in managing Levy's case.

Levy's criminal record includes numerous sexual assaults, including attacks on public transport and a prison officer. He pleaded not guilty to all charges but was convicted following the trial.